Both grills are built to last with high-quality ceramic materials that ensure excellent heat retention. They also come with advanced features like the 3-tier Divide & Conquer system and the SlōRoller Hyperbolic Smoke Chamber, which enhance their versatility and performance. However, the Big Joe III is significantly heavier than the Classic Joe III, which might be a consideration if you plan to move the grill frequently. In this article, we’ll explore the key differences between these two popular models to help you make an informed decision.
Kamado Joe Classic Joe III 18-inch Charcoal Grill
Pros:
- Compact for small spaces
- Great heat retention
- Versatile 3-tier system
- Durable ceramic build
- Easy temperature control
Cons:
- Heavy to move around
- Complex assembly
- Limited cooking space
- Requires frequent cleaning
- High charcoal consumption
Kamado Joe Big Joe III 24-inch Ceramic Grill
Pros:
- Large cooking surface
- Excellent heat retention
- Versatile for large groups
- Sturdy build quality
- Wide accessory compatibility
Cons:
- Very heavy to relocate
- Complex assembly process
- High charcoal usage
- Takes longer to clean
- More expensive
Kamado Joe Classic vs. Big Joe: Cooking Surface Area Comparison
The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III 18-inch Charcoal Grill offers a cooking surface of 256 square inches. With its 3-tier Divide & Conquer system, you can optimize this space to cook a variety of foods at different temperatures simultaneously. This makes it a versatile choice for those who need a compact yet efficient grilling area.
On the other hand, the Kamado Joe Big Joe III 24-inch Ceramic Grill provides a more extensive cooking surface of 450 square inches. This larger area is ideal for those who frequently host large gatherings or prefer to cook multiple dishes at once. The 3-tier system on the Big Joe also allows for diverse cooking techniques, making it a powerhouse for any grilling enthusiast.
Kamado Joe Classic Joe III 18-inch Charcoal Grill
Kamado Joe Big Joe III 24-inch Ceramic Grill
Kamado Joe Classic vs. Big Joe: Weight Comparison
The weight of a grill can greatly affect its portability and ease of handling, especially if you plan to move it around your backyard or take it on trips. The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III weighs approximately 282 pounds, making it quite hefty but manageable for occasional movement with the help of another person.
On the other hand, the Kamado Joe Big Joe III is significantly heavier, tipping the scales at about 487 pounds. This additional weight makes it much more challenging to move without specialized equipment. The substantial weight difference between these two models highlights the Big Joe’s larger cooking surface but also its reduced portability.
Kamado Joe Classic vs. Big Joe: Material Quality
The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and the Big Joe III are both built to last, thanks to their high-quality ceramic construction. This material is known for its ability to retain heat, which is essential for even cooking. Both grills are also equipped with heavy-duty galvanized steel rolling carts with locking wheels, providing stability and ease of movement.
The Classic Joe III is an 18-inch grill, making it suitable for smaller gatherings, whereas the Big Joe III is a 24-inch grill, perfect for larger groups. Despite their size difference, both grills feature the same durable ceramic material that can withstand high temperatures without cracking.
Additionally, both models include stainless steel cooking grates, which are resistant to rust and easy to clean. The patented SlōRoller Hyperbolic Smoke Chamber is another shared feature, using advanced technology to distribute smoke and heat evenly for better flavor. The Kontrol Tower Top Vent, made from powder-coated cast aluminum, ensures consistent airflow management, further enhancing the durability and performance of these grills.
One notable difference is the weight. The Big Joe III is significantly heavier, which can be a consideration for those who need to move the grill frequently. However, both models come with an Air Lift Hinge that reduces the dome weight, making it easier to lift the lid with minimal effort.
Assembly Complexity: Kamado Joe Classic vs. Big Joe
Setting up a new grill can be quite a task, and the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III 18-inch Charcoal Grill and the Kamado Joe Big Joe III 24-inch Ceramic Grill are no exception. The Classic Joe III comes well-packaged and includes clear instructions. However, due to its weight, it’s recommended to have an extra pair of hands during assembly, especially when lifting the main body onto the stand. The process involves assembling the stand first and then attaching various components like the side shelves, grill grates, and the SlōRoller insert. Users have noted that while the instructions are clear, the overall process can be time-consuming, taking a few hours to complete.
On the other hand, the Big Joe III is even larger and heavier, making its assembly an even bigger challenge. Just like the Classic Joe, it arrives well-packaged with detailed instructions. However, due to its size and weight, lifting the grill onto the stand requires at least two strong individuals. The assembly process is similar to that of the Classic Joe III, involving the setup of the stand and attaching the various parts. The larger size means there are more components to handle, which can add to the complexity and time required for assembly. Some users have reported difficulties with aligning the lid and ensuring the bands are properly seated, which can add to the frustration.
Kamado Joe Classic Joe III 18-inch Charcoal Grill
Kamado Joe Big Joe III 24-inch Ceramic Grill
Kamado Joe Classic Joe III vs. Big Joe III: Temperature Retention
Temperature retention is a key factor when choosing a grill, especially for those long smoking sessions. Both the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and the Big Joe III excel in this area, but there are some differences worth noting.
The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III, with its 18-inch size, is known for its impressive heat retention. The ceramic build ensures that the heat stays consistent, making it easier to maintain a steady temperature for hours. Users have reported that once the grill reaches the desired temperature, it holds it with minimal adjustments needed.
On the other hand, the Kamado Joe Big Joe III, being a larger 24-inch grill, also benefits from the same ceramic construction. However, its larger size means it requires more charcoal to reach and maintain high temperatures. Despite this, the Big Joe III is praised for its ability to retain heat over extended periods, making it ideal for large gatherings and cooking bigger cuts of meat.
In terms of overall performance, both grills are excellent, but the Classic Joe III might be more fuel-efficient due to its smaller size. The Big Joe III, while requiring more fuel, offers more cooking space and can handle larger amounts of food without compromising on heat retention.
For those who prioritize fuel efficiency and ease of temperature control, the Classic Joe III might be the better option. However, if you need the extra cooking space and don’t mind using a bit more charcoal, the Big Joe III is a fantastic choice.
Kamado Joe Classic vs. Big Joe: Warranty Comparison
Both the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and the Big Joe III come with a limited lifetime warranty on ceramic parts, which shows the brand’s commitment to durability and customer satisfaction. The metal and cast iron parts have a 5-year warranty, while the heat deflector and pizza stone are covered for 3 years.
For electronics and the thermometer, the warranty period is 2 years. This comprehensive coverage ensures that you have peace of mind regardless of which model you choose. However, it’s always a good idea to read the warranty terms carefully to understand what is and isn’t covered.
Kamado Joe Classic vs. Big Joe: Accessories Compatibility
When deciding between the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and the Big Joe III, one key factor to consider is the range of accessories available for each grill. Both models are known for their high-quality build and impressive cooking capabilities, but how do they stack up in terms of accessories compatibility?
The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III is compatible with a vast array of accessories. This 18-inch grill can accommodate the Joetisserie, which allows for rotisserie-style cooking, and the iKamand, a smart temperature control device. Additionally, it works with various grill grates, heat deflectors, and the popular SloRoller insert for enhanced smoking capabilities. These accessories are designed to fit seamlessly with the Classic Joe III, offering users a versatile cooking experience.
On the other hand, the Kamado Joe Big Joe III, with its larger 24-inch cooking surface, also supports a wide range of accessories. Due to its size, it can handle larger versions of the same accessories available for the Classic Joe III. This includes the Big Joetisserie, which is perfect for larger cuts of meat, and the iKamand for precise temperature control. The Big Joe III also accommodates multiple grill grates, heat deflectors, and the SloRoller insert. Its larger size provides even more flexibility for various cooking techniques and larger gatherings.
In terms of accessories compatibility, both the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and Big Joe III offer extensive options that enhance their functionality. However, the Big Joe III’s larger size gives it a slight edge in versatility, as it can handle more substantial accessories and larger quantities of food. This makes it an excellent choice for those who frequently cook for large groups or want the flexibility to experiment with different cooking styles.
Kamado Joe Classic vs. Big Joe: Ease of Cleaning
Cleaning your grill after a good cookout should be straightforward, allowing you to spend more time enjoying your meal and less time scrubbing. The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III, with its 18-inch cooking space, offers simplicity in maintenance. Its smaller size means fewer surfaces to clean, and the ceramics are designed to burn off grease and residue at high temperatures. This makes it easy to maintain a clean cooking environment with minimal effort.
On the other hand, the Kamado Joe Big Joe III, with its larger 24-inch grilling surface, may require a bit more time and effort when it comes to cleaning. The larger cooking area means more space for grease and food particles to accumulate. However, like the Classic Joe III, it features high-quality ceramic materials that can burn off leftovers at high temperatures, simplifying the process. The extra space might mean a bit more scrubbing, but the overall cleaning method remains user-friendly.
Kamado Joe Classic Joe III 18-inch Charcoal Grill
Kamado Joe Big Joe III 24-inch Ceramic Grill
Heat Distribution in Kamado Joe Classic vs. Big Joe
Heat distribution is a key factor in grilling, ensuring that your food cooks evenly. The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III 18-inch and the Big Joe III 24-inch both boast advanced features aimed at achieving this goal. The SlōRoller Hyperbolic Smoke Chamber in both models is designed to spread heat and smoke in rolling waves, minimizing hotspots and maximizing flavor.
The main difference between the two models lies in their size. The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III, with its 18-inch cooking surface, is suitable for smaller gatherings and offers great control over heat distribution. On the other hand, the Big Joe III’s 24-inch surface provides more cooking space, making it ideal for larger groups. Its larger size, however, doesn’t compromise its ability to evenly distribute heat.
Kamado Joe Classic vs. Big Joe: Customer Support Comparison
Evaluating customer support for Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and Big Joe III reveals some key differences. Many reviewers have praised Kamado Joe’s customer service for its helpfulness and efficiency. Customers often mention how quickly their issues were resolved and the friendly attitude of the support team.
On the other hand, some users of the Big Joe III have experienced less satisfactory interactions. While many still report positive experiences, there are instances where support was slower or less responsive. A few customers noted that their problems took longer to resolve, which can be frustrating when dealing with high-end products.
Conclusion: Kamado Joe Classic vs. Big Joe
In this conclusion, we summarize the key points of the comparison and declare the Kamado Joe Big Joe III as the preferred choice based on the following reasons: The Big Joe III offers a larger cooking surface, making it ideal for bigger gatherings and more versatile cooking. Despite its heavier weight and more complex assembly, its extensive accessory compatibility, excellent heat retention, and robust material quality make it a powerhouse for avid grillers. This decision aligns with the thematic concept of Kamado Joe Classic vs. Big Joe, emphasizing the trade-offs between size, portability, and cooking capacity.
Questions & Answers:
Question: What is the main difference in cooking surface area between the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and Big Joe III?
Answer: The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III has a cooking surface of 256 square inches, while the Big Joe III offers a larger cooking area of 450 square inches.
Question: How does the weight of the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III compare to the Big Joe III?
Answer: The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III weighs about 282 pounds, making it easier to move than the Big Joe III, which weighs approximately 487 pounds.
Question: Are both the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and Big Joe III made from the same materials?
Answer: Yes, both grills are made from high-quality ceramic, which is great for heat retention and durability. They also come with stainless steel cooking grates and heavy-duty galvanized steel rolling carts.
Question: Which grill is easier to assemble, the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III or the Big Joe III?
Answer: The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III is generally easier to assemble due to its smaller size and weight. The Big Joe III is larger and heavier, making the assembly process more challenging and time-consuming.
Question: How do the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and Big Joe III compare in terms of temperature retention?
Answer: Both grills excel in temperature retention due to their ceramic construction. However, the Classic Joe III is more fuel-efficient because of its smaller size, while the Big Joe III requires more charcoal but offers a larger cooking space.
Question: What are the warranty terms for the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and Big Joe III?
Answer: Both models come with a limited lifetime warranty on ceramic parts, a 5-year warranty on metal and cast iron parts, a 3-year warranty on heat deflectors and pizza stones, and a 2-year warranty on electronics and thermometers.
Question: Can I use the same accessories with both the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and Big Joe III?
Answer: Yes, both grills are compatible with a wide range of accessories, but the Big Joe III can accommodate larger versions of these accessories due to its bigger size.
Question: Which grill is easier to clean, the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III or the Big Joe III?
Answer: The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III is easier to clean due to its smaller cooking surface. The Big Joe III, while still user-friendly, requires more effort to clean because of its larger cooking area.